09-10-2017: Difference between revisions

From XPUB & Lens-Based wiki
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Notes from "Alien Agency - Experimental Encounters with Art in the making" Chris Salter
== Notes from "Alien Agency - Experimental Encounters with Art in the making" Chris Salter ==


Boundary leaking, blurring in and out, the body and the room continue as a pattern across other participants. “ I loved the beginning because I couldn ’ t feel where my body ended and the space began ” ; “ as much as there was no visual information, in the dark you still see .   .   . you still see .   .   . I don ’ t know what you see .   .   . but you see something, you know like a black cloud. I would define it like that.
''Boundary leaking, blurring in and out, the body and the room continue as a pattern across other participants. “ I loved the beginning because I couldn ’ t feel where my body ended and the space began ” ; “ as much as there was no visual information, in the dark you still see .   .   . you still see .   .   . I don ’ t know what you see .   .   . but you see something, you know like a black cloud. I would define it like that. ''


If these forces from without introduce sensorial transience in the visitors, they also shake the stable self, remove the ability to hold onto something in the world, obscure easily defined borders between subject and object, visible and felt, perceived and imagined
• Non-human forces can introduce sensorial transience, shaking the perception of the stable self, losing a grasp on the outside world, redefining the the edges between subject and object, visible and felt, perceived and imagined


For otherness. “ I had begun as an artist, as one who would manipulate the elements of a reality into a work of art in the image of my creative integrity; I end by recording, as humbly and accurately as I can, the logics of a reality which had forced me to recognize its integrity and to abandon my manipulations ” (Maya Deren). 3
''"I had begun as an artist, as one who would manipulate the elements of a reality into a work of art in the image of my creative integrity; I end by recording, as humbly and accurately as I can, the logics of a reality which had forced me to recognize its integrity and to abandon my manipulations ” (Maya Deren)''


a sensory environment for one person at a time that explores the ability to perceptually detect the smallest changes in visual, tactile, and auditory stimuli.
to perceptually detect the smallest changes in visual, tactile, and auditory stimuli is


Aristotle s “ analogies among the separation of forms of sense appear increasingly uncertain ”not only in the “ perplexity ”of touch being “ not one sense but many ”but also in our age of cross-modal neuroscience and multisensory integration in which neurons in the superior colliculus of the brain actually have been proven to deal with more than one sense modality.  
• There are way more than Aristotle's 5 senses. "cross-modal neuroscience and multisensory integration in which neurons in the superior colliculus of the brain actually have been proven to deal with more than one sense modality."


the fluctuating interplay between a sensing subject ”and “ things perceived ”by that subject; matter in the world that, due to its electromagnetic and vibratory nature and makeup, impacts the sensory receptors of human, animal, or vegetal. It goes without saying that this interplay is not altogether clear, because the encounter between perceiver and perceived is itself subject to flux and modulation.
• The changing dialectic between a sensing subject and being perceived by that subject is not altogether discrete, as matter in the world that, due to its electromagnetic and vibratory nature and makeup, impacts the sensory receptors of human and non-human. this interplay is not altogether clear, because the encounter between perceiver and perceived is itself subject to flux and modulation


the understanding that the human “ sensorium ”is a direct product of culture.
• The human sense matrix is a direct product of culture


“ The ways we use our senses, and the ways we create and understand the sensory world, are shaped by culture. Perception is informed not only by the personal meaning a sensation has for us but also for the social value it carries. ”  
''“ The ways we use our senses, and the ways we create and understand the sensory world, are shaped by culture. Perception is informed not only by the personal meaning a sensation has for us but also for the social value it carries. ”  
''
• dystoposthesia: the feeling of being forever out of place due to adverse reactions to everyday effluvia


the sensorial sufferers of “ dystoposthesia ”(the feeling of being forever out of place due to adverse reactions to everyday effluvia);
• affect, technology and anthropology are inherently linked. Temp, light, colour, sound, smell elicit emotional and physiological responses that modulate peoples' experiential affect.


suggests that affect, technology, and anthropology are not as far removed from each other as we might think. “ The controllable items connected with the internal and external 176 Part III environment of a service facility — temperature, light, color, sound and aroma — that elicit an emotional and physiological reaction from customers ’[these items] .   .   . powerfully modulate patrons ’ ‘ experiential affect, ’not only helping to usher them to machines but to immerse them in the zone and keep them there. ”
• 2 tensions -- Brecht: proposes a critical distance between spectator and event  Artaud: An attack on the spectator's sensibility on all sides


the creation of signification is coming to grips with the fact that the immense richness of human sensation and imagination has only so much to do with the human but also with the dazzling material forces and affects circulating through the world.  
''I’m forever pulled between the tensions of immersion and artifice. To disorient the spectators while heightening how the world operates. Disorientation, defamiliarization marked by sensorial transformation
''
• The thermal cosmology of the Tzotzil of Chiapas relate images and symbols with heat and cold to the external world, creating a multisensory symbolic system that permeates daily life.  


The tension again between distance and absorption. Estrangement and perceptual destabilization. On the one hand, Brecht ’ s theory of verfremdung , of defamiliarization, proposes a critical distance between the spectator and the event. On the other, Artaud ’ s notion of cruelty aims for the opposite, “ an attack on the spectator ’ s sensibility on all sides.
• Intermodal (multisensory) sensations factor a key role in religion and spiritual practice. Synaesthesia and infrasensory signals abound. Sound becomes the vehicle for divine power to awe worshippers and exchange messages with the gods. Voices detached from the body transform into spectral presences that become cult spirits incarnate.  


I’m forever pulled between the tensions of immersion and artifice. To disorient the spectators while heightening how the world operates. Disorientation, defamiliarization marked by sensorial transformation
• The acoustic intensity produced by such sounding apparatuses not only intimidate and terrify those outside of the cult, but are also alien to those who, in fact, produce them. If such sounds “ produce an experience without an object, ”then perhaps peak religious experiences operate at “ the intersection of the senses.


the “ thermal cosmology ”of the Tzotzil, Mayan descendants who make their home in the Chiapas region of Mexico, thermal images and symbols abound: “ our father heat ”(the sun), the colors of food (corn is hot whereas potatoes are cold), ceremonies in which heat is essential, healers ’careful attention to temperature changes in the body. The Tzotzil ’ s is a color-coded cosmos replete with 180 Part III rituals that emphasize the role of heat across cooking, language, symbolic forms: “ thermal symbolism .   .   . integrated into a multisensory symbolic system. ”
• When sound and vibration is only analysed from human centred subjectivity, it neglects the agency of the vibrational encounter and ignores the nonhuman participants of this vibrational nexus


the discussion of sensation ’ s role in religion and spiritual practice — the play of things such as synesthesia and “ infrasensory signals. ” Sound becomes the dominant means to “ awe worshippers and exchange messages with the gods. amplified voices into spectral presences do not just represent the gods — “ they are the cult spirits”
Sound references are associated with experience that creates a habitual expectation of their affect


Tuzin ’ s analysis also again brings up the tension between the pure experience of sound and vibration and the human cultural interpretation and framing of such sounds. “ The phenomenological anthropocentrism of almost all musical and sonic analysis, obsessed with individualized subjective feeling,  denigrates the vibrational nexus at the altar of human audition, thereby neglecting the agency distributed around a vibrational encounter and ignoring the nonhuman participants of the nexus of experience. ”
''How could we make a room fluctuate at the border of the phantasmal?''


• Experiences of concentrated vision (visual stimuli) can generate shifts in consciousness


auditory ‘ images ’are associated with a set of memories and experiences which become ‘ habitual ’in a given social and cultural environment
• Is it possible to recreate an experience that produces palpable affect beyond sensorial otherness without the usual religious or cultural tools?


• Ritual is performative, a systematised series of repeated practice within set out times and places that constitute significance


How could we make a room fluctuate at the border of the phantasmal?
• Experimentation allows for alienness to creep into practice, with the unknown as the goal, it is also unknown how the material will affect the maker


Unrelenting vision can be compared to concentrated vision that heralds a shift in consciousness
• To create an extraordinary experience, the space has to become sacred to enable such an affect
• To minimise sight allows for other senses to become heightened.  Vibrations of different intensities allows for an awareness of touch to oscillate. Merging 2 senses allows for intermingling at the borders, at which point they begin to blur.


Are we after the mysterium tremendum, something beyond cultural accounts of sensorial otherness that could leap over into producing affect that will be palpable, sensual, and meaningful outside of religious or even cultural experience?
• Hallucinations often occur within a pre-established set of stored material where shapes and colour waver


“ ritualization ”suggests that ritual is performative — a repeated and formalized practice of particular actions within carefully determined times and places that constitute meaning as they unfold
• Synesthesia occurs in hallucinatory drug use that defy cultural bounds and reference the wiring of the brain. The mythical dramaturgy experienced by some tribes on ayahuasca can only be seen by them. But the repetitive
luminous patterns perceived during the first stage of the trip represent neurophysiologically an entirely different aspect of the experience.


To construct rituals is intriguing but very tricky territory. It brings to mind those terrible experiences of bad theater and performance art events in which suburban born and raised kids try to get “ primitive ”or galleries and warehouses where one enters to the sound of Tibetan bowls, the sight of rows of flickering votive candles, and the smell of incense, the kind that fills the air of new age bookstores. These kinds of “ orientalist ”(in Edward Said ’ s sense of the term) stagings are not only politically problematic in reinforcing stereotypes of exotic others but also aesthetically dubious.
''Our work is nothing but translation. Not mirrors or models but assemblages that might provoke sensations to occur. New visceral acts enabled through a technologically orchestrated event that rattles the body, vibrates the soul, and yet is far removed from the original source. What position do we occupy? Insiders, outsiders, or a hybrid of the two?''


• Experiences between technique and perceivers are hard to quantify. Affects operate from a distance but also collapse separation. Sensation are part of the human experience and part apparatus that connect, apply their influence, then leave. They operate on the sensorium and the body without leaving traces easily transmuted into words.  ''Is this the experience of an ethnographic encounter with the alien?''


The alienness is not only in the fact that we don ’ t really know what we are making; we also don ’ t know what these materials will do to us.
an attempt to “ put people into a certain time/space to procure an extraordinary experience. ”There has to be a kind of “ sacralization of space ” to enable such experience to occur.
A strong augmentation of one sense, like vibration at different intensities to give
the awareness of touch in different manifestations. The other is to work with more
than one sense and mingle them together, say touch and smell, so that they start to
modulate each other and the borders between one and the other begin to blur.
But what is most striking is the fact that “ the sphere of hallucinations ”that the anthropologist describes “ is one of subjective interpretations in which the person projects a set of preestablished,
stored material upon the wavering screen of shapes and colors. ”
The synesthetic sensory visions elicited by the drugs are both culturally specific and
cut across the container of culture into the very neurophysiological wiring of the brain
under the influence of psychedelic chemicals. The mythical dramaturgy experienced
by the Tukano and Desana “ can be seen only be members of their society. But the repetitive
luminous patterns perceived during the first stage of the toxic condition represent
neurophysiologically an entirely different aspect of the experience. ”
Extremes of light and darkness, hot and cold occupy the hexagonal landscape or
perhaps before the visitors encounter the hexagon — a black space preceding the intense
color and sound saturation. Then, combinations of the senses such as darkness, scent,
vibration, flashes of phosphene-like images in the air, similar to the ones that ReichelDolmatoff
describes Desana men seeing during their rituals of self-transformation under
the influence of the holy vine.
Our work is nothing but translation. Not mirrors or models but assemblages that
might provoke sensations to occur. New visceral acts enabled through a technologically
orchestrated event that rattles the body, vibrates the soul, and yet is far removed
from the original source. What position do we occupy? Insiders, outsiders, or a hybrid
of the two?
The written account brought about by the struggle to describe the assemblage of
conditions and materials that enable encounters between perceivers and the magical
properties of techniques, of course, takes place at a distance. Affects operate on us
from afar and, at the same time, collapse distance. These techniques of sensation that
are part human sensorium and part instruments and apparatuses link up, exert their
influence, and then run from us. They operate on the body and the senses, defying the
neat stability to capture them in writing and, indeed, in the container of culture itself —
almost effacing it. Is this the experience of an ethnographic encounter with the alien?




Line 118: Line 87:
of unruly experience, not only with human culture but also with that on the verge
of unruly experience, not only with human culture but also with that on the verge
beyond us.
beyond us.
Western art is ontological theater for a principled Cartesian split between
active, controlling human agents and a passive, machine-like, and dominated world.
The selves elicited by these
works are nonmodern ones in which boundaries between self and other are no longer
so apparent; recognition of alien agency means just that — an openness and curiosity
about what the world can do, unconstrained by scientific representations of what
exists and what does not. This openness points east: Buddhism and the modern self as
an unfortunate illusion; zen, the tao, and humanity as caught up in the endless flux
of becoming. Something is happening here, and you don ’ t know what it is. A sense
of danger and of shame. Drugs, visions, altered states, madness, the loss of control,
surrender — everything we ’ ve been taught to feel bad about. Modernity has its defenses
in place, and the police are inside us
it begins to look like something one could
live — a stance, a specific way of being and acting in the world, one that recognizes the
flow of becoming rather than dreaming of mastery
David Skrbina ’ s 2005 Panpsychism
in the West demonstrates, philosophical debates about whether things outside of human
life, such as plants, animals, or brute matter, have consciousness or sentience inherent in them
have squarely occupied centuries of both Western and Eastern thought. Panpsychism, writes
Skrbina , is the concept that “ all objects or systems of objects, possess a singular inner experience
of the world around them ”Such objects could be said to harbor “ mind or mind-like
qualities, ”that is, singular experience inherent to them, without entailing anthropocentric
notions such as consciousness, life, thought or cognition, perception, or soul. From the monism
of pre-Socratic philosophers such as Thales (all is water), Anaximenes (all is air), Anaximander (all
is a boundless, infinite substance called the apeiron), and, most well-known, Heraclitus of Ephesus
(all is fire and flux), to Spinoza and Leibniz,

Revision as of 15:59, 10 October 2017

Notes from "Alien Agency - Experimental Encounters with Art in the making" Chris Salter

Boundary leaking, blurring in and out, the body and the room continue as a pattern across other participants. “ I loved the beginning because I couldn ’ t feel where my body ended and the space began ” ; “ as much as there was no visual information, in the dark you still see .   .   . you still see .   .   . I don ’ t know what you see .   .   . but you see something, you know like a black cloud. I would define it like that.

• Non-human forces can introduce sensorial transience, shaking the perception of the stable self, losing a grasp on the outside world, redefining the the edges between subject and object, visible and felt, perceived and imagined

"I had begun as an artist, as one who would manipulate the elements of a reality into a work of art in the image of my creative integrity; I end by recording, as humbly and accurately as I can, the logics of a reality which had forced me to recognize its integrity and to abandon my manipulations ” (Maya Deren)

• to perceptually detect the smallest changes in visual, tactile, and auditory stimuli is

• There are way more than Aristotle's 5 senses. "cross-modal neuroscience and multisensory integration in which neurons in the superior colliculus of the brain actually have been proven to deal with more than one sense modality."

• The changing dialectic between a sensing subject and being perceived by that subject is not altogether discrete, as matter in the world that, due to its electromagnetic and vibratory nature and makeup, impacts the sensory receptors of human and non-human. this interplay is not altogether clear, because the encounter between perceiver and perceived is itself subject to flux and modulation

• The human sense matrix is a direct product of culture

“ The ways we use our senses, and the ways we create and understand the sensory world, are shaped by culture. Perception is informed not only by the personal meaning a sensation has for us but also for the social value it carries. ” • dystoposthesia: the feeling of being forever out of place due to adverse reactions to everyday effluvia

• affect, technology and anthropology are inherently linked. Temp, light, colour, sound, smell elicit emotional and physiological responses that modulate peoples' experiential affect.

• 2 tensions -- Brecht: proposes a critical distance between spectator and event Artaud: An attack on the spectator's sensibility on all sides

I’m forever pulled between the tensions of immersion and artifice. To disorient the spectators while heightening how the world operates. Disorientation, defamiliarization marked by sensorial transformation • The thermal cosmology of the Tzotzil of Chiapas relate images and symbols with heat and cold to the external world, creating a multisensory symbolic system that permeates daily life.

• Intermodal (multisensory) sensations factor a key role in religion and spiritual practice. Synaesthesia and infrasensory signals abound. Sound becomes the vehicle for divine power to awe worshippers and exchange messages with the gods. Voices detached from the body transform into spectral presences that become cult spirits incarnate.

• The acoustic intensity produced by such sounding apparatuses not only intimidate and terrify those outside of the cult, but are also alien to those who, in fact, produce them. If such sounds “ produce an experience without an object, ”then perhaps peak religious experiences operate at “ the intersection of the senses. ”

• When sound and vibration is only analysed from human centred subjectivity, it neglects the agency of the vibrational encounter and ignores the nonhuman participants of this vibrational nexus

• Sound references are associated with experience that creates a habitual expectation of their affect

How could we make a room fluctuate at the border of the phantasmal?

• Experiences of concentrated vision (visual stimuli) can generate shifts in consciousness

• Is it possible to recreate an experience that produces palpable affect beyond sensorial otherness without the usual religious or cultural tools?

• Ritual is performative, a systematised series of repeated practice within set out times and places that constitute significance

• Experimentation allows for alienness to creep into practice, with the unknown as the goal, it is also unknown how the material will affect the maker

• To create an extraordinary experience, the space has to become sacred to enable such an affect

• To minimise sight allows for other senses to become heightened. Vibrations of different intensities allows for an awareness of touch to oscillate. Merging 2 senses allows for intermingling at the borders, at which point they begin to blur.

• Hallucinations often occur within a pre-established set of stored material where shapes and colour waver

• Synesthesia occurs in hallucinatory drug use that defy cultural bounds and reference the wiring of the brain. The mythical dramaturgy experienced by some tribes on ayahuasca can only be seen by them. But the repetitive luminous patterns perceived during the first stage of the trip represent neurophysiologically an entirely different aspect of the experience.

Our work is nothing but translation. Not mirrors or models but assemblages that might provoke sensations to occur. New visceral acts enabled through a technologically orchestrated event that rattles the body, vibrates the soul, and yet is far removed from the original source. What position do we occupy? Insiders, outsiders, or a hybrid of the two?

• Experiences between technique and perceivers are hard to quantify. Affects operate from a distance but also collapse separation. Sensation are part of the human experience and part apparatus that connect, apply their influence, then leave. They operate on the sensorium and the body without leaving traces easily transmuted into words. Is this the experience of an ethnographic encounter with the alien?


Just as perception is not necessarily

local but tends to affect and life doesn ’ t situate itself in bodies and organisms, Displace as a lived experience within an unfamiliar world suggests that culture is not contained in fixed symbols, in containers, in sense ratios, series, modalities, knowing . Culture emerges; it comes about through imaginative encounters with the evanescent, more than human world. This is what the artwork does. It functions as an assemblage of emergent perceptions and affects. What the public ’ s encounter with Displace shows is the very possibility of sensing and experiencing this formation.

How is it possible that things, stuff at a distance, at a remove, beyond us, not even human, can exert such powerful effects and affects on our bodies, souls, and world?

artists are making a different claim about the world — one that through acts of “ practical aesthetics ”(Jill Bennett) enacts concepts, manipulates materials, and enables the assemblage for publics to encounter. 4 This aesthetic, affective encounter is not to be underestimated; it is that which, as Guattari argued, “ may irreversibly mark the course of an existence .   .   . something which draws the subject towards his or her own recreation and reinvention. ”

Alienness provokes us to theorize culture anew; to recognize its temporal, emergent, dynamic being; not contained, elusive to capture and success. Agency, acts, behaviors cannot be described in words only but also in their temporal unfolding, their performances. 11 The artistic act makes the conditions possible to destabilize the known and reinvent it anew. In other words, in what I ’ ve attempted to tell, alienness may also help us rethink what it means to create an account of unruly experience, not only with human culture but also with that on the verge beyond us.

Western art is ontological theater for a principled Cartesian split between active, controlling human agents and a passive, machine-like, and dominated world.

The selves elicited by these works are nonmodern ones in which boundaries between self and other are no longer so apparent; recognition of alien agency means just that — an openness and curiosity about what the world can do, unconstrained by scientific representations of what exists and what does not. This openness points east: Buddhism and the modern self as an unfortunate illusion; zen, the tao, and humanity as caught up in the endless flux of becoming. Something is happening here, and you don ’ t know what it is. A sense of danger and of shame. Drugs, visions, altered states, madness, the loss of control, surrender — everything we ’ ve been taught to feel bad about. Modernity has its defenses in place, and the police are inside us


it begins to look like something one could live — a stance, a specific way of being and acting in the world, one that recognizes the flow of becoming rather than dreaming of mastery

David Skrbina ’ s 2005 Panpsychism in the West demonstrates, philosophical debates about whether things outside of human life, such as plants, animals, or brute matter, have consciousness or sentience inherent in them have squarely occupied centuries of both Western and Eastern thought. Panpsychism, writes Skrbina , is the concept that “ all objects or systems of objects, possess a singular inner experience of the world around them ”Such objects could be said to harbor “ mind or mind-like qualities, ”that is, singular experience inherent to them, without entailing anthropocentric notions such as consciousness, life, thought or cognition, perception, or soul. From the monism of pre-Socratic philosophers such as Thales (all is water), Anaximenes (all is air), Anaximander (all is a boundless, infinite substance called the apeiron), and, most well-known, Heraclitus of Ephesus (all is fire and flux), to Spinoza and Leibniz,