Graphic Scores-avant-garde: Difference between revisions

From XPUB & Lens-Based wiki
No edit summary
 
(17 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Pad: https://pad.pzimediadesign.nl/p/pts-2017-01-26
=Graphic scores in 20th century avant-garde=
=Graphic scores in 20th century avant-garde=
http://www.juilliard.edu/sites/juilliard.edu/files/journal/2012/05/cage-john.jpg
John Cage will be the center figure of this session. Not only due to its the 20th century Western avant-garde music, but moreover, due to the extensive of his exploration of graphical scores, which range from more conventional open scores to systems for generating scores.
John Cage will be the center figure of this session. Not only due to its the 20th century Western avant-garde music, but moreover, due to the extensive of his exploration of graphical scores, which range from more conventional open scores to systems for generating scores.


== why graphic scores ==
== why graphic scores? ==
Keeping the focus on music or sound art, it should be asked '''why are graphic scores needed?''' Why were they employed in musical composition?
Keeping the focus on music or sound art, it should be asked '''why are graphic scores needed?''' Why were they employed in musical composition?


Line 9: Line 14:
'''What are the approaches and ideas that graphic scores is better suited to express, than conventional westerner notation?'''
'''What are the approaches and ideas that graphic scores is better suited to express, than conventional westerner notation?'''


<div style="background:yellow">
* '''description of certain sounds''' such noise, extended playing techniques (e.g. rubbing fingers on skin, bowing a cymbal, processing the sound, etc) that fall outside the scope of western musical notation
* '''description of the instrument configurations''' and setting of an instrument (e.g. the patch of modular synthesizer or preparation of a piano)
* capacity to change the '''form''' of the composition significantly, with each interpretation
* capacity to change the '''roles and responsibilities''' of composer and interpret 
</div>


* instrument configuration
==John Cage ''Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano'' (1946–48)==
** John Cage ''Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano'' (1946-1948) - instrument configuration
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/Prepared-Piano.jpg
** David Tudor ''Rainforest'' - instrument configuration
 
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/Directions-Prepared-Piano.jpg
 
* the prepared piano entered Cage's repertoire with the composition ''Bacchanale''(1940) for a dance piece by Syvilla Fort 
* Cage wanted to compose a piece with a large amount percussion sounds, however he lacked the space on space for this, and was only provided with a piano 
* he started experimenting with placing metal, rubber and wood objects on the piano strings, to obtain percussion like sounds
* his preparation provided to a pianist a pallet of sounds and an interface that could only be achieved by a large number of percussionists
 
* although the score for ''Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano'' is not a graphic score, it included graphic and text notes on how to prepare the piano
 
http://dreixel.net/hauptwerk/image/cage2.png
http://dreixel.net/hauptwerk/image/cage1.png
http://dreixel.net/hauptwerk/image/cage3.png
 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3w7GeJCLpJc
 
==John Cage ''Music of Changes'' (1951)==
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/1e/Music-of-changes-4-1.gif
 
* composed for David Tudor
* in its compositional process Cage use the divination text ''I Ching: The book of Change'' as a chance mechanism
** by tossing coins one arrives at an hexagram and a corresponding ambiguous text
* change determined the sonority (not only pitches, but also complex sounds), durations and dynamics of the different sound events of the piece
 
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6b/Iching-hexagram-08.svg Hexagram 8 ''Holding together''
 
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAjKD12RkEY
* http://www.ichingonline.net
* [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Ching ''I Ching'']
* [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_hexagrams_of_the_I_Ching List of ''I Ching'' hexagrams]
 
 
==Jonh Cage ''Imaginary Landscape N°4'' (1951)==
* An electronic composition for 12 radios, operated by two performers each
* the ''I Ching'' was used to create the score: notating volume and tune control
* More than created by chance this work was ''indeterminate'', as the source of sound - the radio spectrum - it is not known
 
https://chrissypianist.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/imaginary-landscape-2-pg-1.jpg
 
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yV-kWU1Z5u8
* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRa0j_EIth0
 
==David Tudor ''Rainforest'' (I - 1968)(IV - 1973)==
http://davidtudor.org/Graphics/rfDiagram73.jpg
 
* "sound transformations without the use of electronic modulation: the source sounds, when transmitted through the physical materials, will be modified by the resonant nodes of those materials"
* "The contact mikes on the objects pickup the resonant frequencies which one hears when very close to the object, and then are amplified through a loudspeaker as an enhancement"
* "a large group piece actually, any number of people can participate in it… [E]ach person makes their own sculpture, decides how to program it, and performs it themselves"
* score: diagram describing the connection of the piece's constituent elements
* a piece that can compose itself out of its constituent elements
* indeterminacy 
 
 
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-nqUObFXUkjA/TnYhTjAp2fI/AAAAAAAAA4I/GD93eTTBup0/s1600/moogpatch2.jpg
 
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/__w9YdjE55dY/SLv4ixsoBCI/AAAAAAAAAIY/GPS8zTXKEyY/s1600-h/MOTM_Flute_Patchsheet.jpg
 
https://3.bp.blogspot.com/-HVetoUaHXu0/VsVALYBLSOI/AAAAAAAAIt4/TZ7kBzTmSb4/s1600/20160218_141517.jpg
 
* http://davidtudor.org/Works/rainforest.html
* http://composers-inside-electronics.net/rainforest/rainforest/RAINFOREST.html
* https://www.youtube.com/embed/iT9HP48sHTg
* http://www.getty.edu/research/tools/guides_bibliographies/david_tudor/av/rainforest.html
* Holzer, Derek, and Mads BEch Paulszewski. n.d. “Rainforest 2012.” http://macumbista.net/files/rainforest_overview.pdf
* Driscoll, John, and Matt Rogalsky. 2004. “David Tudor’s ‘Rainforest’: An Evolving Exploration of Resonance.” Leonardo Music Journal 14: 25–30. http://www.jstor.org/stable/1513502
* “Vague Terrain 19: Schematic as Score | Vague Terrain.” 2017. Accessed January 24. http://web.archive.org/web/20150227025105/http://vagueterrain.net/journal19.
 
==John Cage ''Fontana Mix'' (1958)==
http://www.bbc.co.uk/staticarchive/5b15f7b4e45ec255d9017f253c4faed1ae95a2f2.jpg
 
* Initially created for composing tape music
* Luciano Berio's invited Cage to compose a tape piece at the studio of the Milan radio
* The piece/score boroughs its name from Cage's Milanese landlady, Signora Fontana
 
* Although initially the score was created for composing tape music pieces, Cage understood it could serve other compositional contexts.
* More than a score, perhaps a meta-score, or a tool that allowed many scores to be created from it.
** ''Aria'' - for single voice
** ''Sounds of Venice'' (1959) - performance
** ''Water Walk'' (1959) - performance. [[#score of Water Walk|Score]] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXOIkT1-QWY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXOIkT1-QWY
** ''Theatre Piece'' (1960) - for 1 to 8 performers of any sort (musicians, dancers, singers)
 
Elements of the score:
* 1 straight line
* 1 graph/grid
* 10 sheets with dots
* 10 sheets with 6 different curved lines: solid or dotted, in 3 different thicknesses
 
=== Water Walk score ===
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/1709953u.jpg
 
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/1709954u.jpg
 
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/1709955u.jpg
 
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/1709956u.jpg
 
http://exhibitions.nypl.org/johncage/sites/exhibitions.nypl.org.johncage/files/1709957u.jpg
 
Floor plan of Water Walk
 
http://johncage.tonspur.at/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/water-walk-2-e1325859034146.jpeg
 
= Bibliography =
Austin, Larry, and Douglas Kahn. 2017. “Source: Music of the Avant Garde: Everything Changes.” Accessed January 24. http://aaaaarg.fail/thing/52b2f8fb307888821400000c.
 
Barry, Robert. 2017. “Graphic Scores: From the Symbolic to the Indexical - The Wire.” The Wire Magazine - Adventures In Modern Music. Accessed January 24. http://www.thewire.co.uk/in-writing/columns/robert-barry_drawing-towards-sound.
 
Driscoll, John, and Matt Rogalsky. 2004. “David Tudor’s ‘Rainforest’: An Evolving Exploration of Resonance.” Leonardo Music Journal 14: 25–30 http://www.jstor.org/stable/1513502.


* '''description of certain sounds'''
Eco, Umberto. 1989. “Poetics of the Open.” In The Open Work, 1–23. Cambridge, Massachusetts+: Harvard Univerity Press. https://monoskop.org/images/6/6b/Eco_Umberto_The_Open_Work.pdf.
** ''Cartridge Music'' ?
<blockquote>
The score of Cartridge Music consists of a page of instructions,
as well as four transparent sheets—one with points, one with circles, another with a circle that looks like a clock face, and a fourth with a dotted curved line with a circle at the end of it—and
twenty pieces of white paper with shapes on them.


The first thing you do is to superimpose the transparencies over the sheet
Holzer, Derek, and Mads BEch Paulszewski. n.d. “Rainforest 2012.” http://macumbista.net/files/rainforest_overview.pdf.
with shapes to get a determination for playing. You may place the
sheets randomly, one on top of the other, only making sure that
the circle at the end of the dotted line contains a point outside a
shape and that the dotted line intersects at least one point within
a shape. Where a dotted line intersects a point within a shape you
produce a sound corresponding to that shape. What Cage means
here is somewhat vague. I think he means that you make a sound
with the object related to that particular shape, but to tell you
the truth I have often simply traced the shape to help me move
my object around to make sounds.


Intersection of
Lucier, Alvin. 2012. Music 109: Notes on Experimental Music. Wesleyan University Press. https://monoskop.org/log/?p=12720.
the dotted line with a point outside the shape indicates auxiliary
sounds made by any means other than those made by the objects
in the cartridges. Cage often uses auxiliary sounds to interrupt
the flow of an otherwise smooth and beautiful piece. You could
amplify nearby microphone stands with contact microphones, for
example. The intersections of the dotted lines with a circle within
and outside a shape may be used to alter dynamic levels and tone
controls respectively. In addition when a circle is intersected by
both a boundary of a shape and the dotted line, a change of object
is indicated.
The dotted line may intersect the clock face at various points.
The clock face is measured in five-second segments. Where it
enters will be your starting time. Where it exits is your ending
time.
</blockquote>


http://www.petergena.com/images/gifs/cartmus.jpg
Pritchett, James. 1993. The Music of John Cage. Cambridge University Press. https://books.google.nl/books?id=riHo22Hi8QAC&printsec=frontcover&redir_esc=y&hl=en#v=onepage&q&f=false.


* '''roles and responsibilities'''
“Realizing Cage’s Cartridge Music | Jaime E Oliver | Computer Music.” 2017. Accessed January 23. http://www.jaimeoliver.pe/recipes/archaeology/cartridge.
** John Cage ''Fontana Mix'' (1958)
** examples from Umberto Eco's ''Open Work'' (1962)


* '''changing form'''
“‘Source: Music of the Avant Garde: Everything Changes.’” 2017. Laboratorie New Music. Accessed January 24. http://www.laboratorienewmusic.com/source-music-of-the-avant-garde-everything-changes/.
** John Cage's ''Theatre Piece'' (1977)


* Chance and indeterminacy
“Vague Terrain 19: Schematic as Score | Vague Terrain.” 2017. Accessed January 24. http://web.archive.org/web/20150227025105/http://vagueterrain.net/journal19.
* Open scores and system scores (the score as a program or a programming language)
* Shifting relationship: composer -> interpreter
* Ambiguity: Cornelious Cardew's Treatise
* Interpreting Cage's Fontana Mix a Theater Piece a score and performing it

Latest revision as of 15:19, 26 January 2017

Pad: https://pad.pzimediadesign.nl/p/pts-2017-01-26

Graphic scores in 20th century avant-garde

cage-john.jpg


John Cage will be the center figure of this session. Not only due to its the 20th century Western avant-garde music, but moreover, due to the extensive of his exploration of graphical scores, which range from more conventional open scores to systems for generating scores.

why graphic scores?

Keeping the focus on music or sound art, it should be asked why are graphic scores needed? Why were they employed in musical composition?

The immediate answer might simply be to express compositional approaches or ideas in a score that conventional westerner notation is not able to do.

What are the approaches and ideas that graphic scores is better suited to express, than conventional westerner notation?


John Cage Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano (1946–48)

Prepared-Piano.jpg

Directions-Prepared-Piano.jpg

  • the prepared piano entered Cage's repertoire with the composition Bacchanale(1940) for a dance piece by Syvilla Fort
  • Cage wanted to compose a piece with a large amount percussion sounds, however he lacked the space on space for this, and was only provided with a piano
  • he started experimenting with placing metal, rubber and wood objects on the piano strings, to obtain percussion like sounds
  • his preparation provided to a pianist a pallet of sounds and an interface that could only be achieved by a large number of percussionists
  • although the score for Sonatas and Interludes for Prepared Piano is not a graphic score, it included graphic and text notes on how to prepare the piano

cage2.png cage1.png cage3.png

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3w7GeJCLpJc

John Cage Music of Changes (1951)

Music-of-changes-4-1.gif

  • composed for David Tudor
  • in its compositional process Cage use the divination text I Ching: The book of Change as a chance mechanism
    • by tossing coins one arrives at an hexagram and a corresponding ambiguous text
  • change determined the sonority (not only pitches, but also complex sounds), durations and dynamics of the different sound events of the piece

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/6b/Iching-hexagram-08.svg Hexagram 8 Holding together


Jonh Cage Imaginary Landscape N°4 (1951)

  • An electronic composition for 12 radios, operated by two performers each
  • the I Ching was used to create the score: notating volume and tune control
  • More than created by chance this work was indeterminate, as the source of sound - the radio spectrum - it is not known

imaginary-landscape-2-pg-1.jpg

David Tudor Rainforest (I - 1968)(IV - 1973)

rfDiagram73.jpg

  • "sound transformations without the use of electronic modulation: the source sounds, when transmitted through the physical materials, will be modified by the resonant nodes of those materials"
  • "The contact mikes on the objects pickup the resonant frequencies which one hears when very close to the object, and then are amplified through a loudspeaker as an enhancement"
  • "a large group piece actually, any number of people can participate in it… [E]ach person makes their own sculpture, decides how to program it, and performs it themselves"
  • score: diagram describing the connection of the piece's constituent elements
  • a piece that can compose itself out of its constituent elements
  • indeterminacy


moogpatch2.jpg

MOTM_Flute_Patchsheet.jpg

20160218_141517.jpg

John Cage Fontana Mix (1958)

5b15f7b4e45ec255d9017f253c4faed1ae95a2f2.jpg

  • Initially created for composing tape music
  • Luciano Berio's invited Cage to compose a tape piece at the studio of the Milan radio
  • The piece/score boroughs its name from Cage's Milanese landlady, Signora Fontana
  • Although initially the score was created for composing tape music pieces, Cage understood it could serve other compositional contexts.
  • More than a score, perhaps a meta-score, or a tool that allowed many scores to be created from it.

Elements of the score:

  • 1 straight line
  • 1 graph/grid
  • 10 sheets with dots
  • 10 sheets with 6 different curved lines: solid or dotted, in 3 different thicknesses

Water Walk score

1709953u.jpg

1709954u.jpg

1709955u.jpg

1709956u.jpg

1709957u.jpg

Floor plan of Water Walk

water-walk-2-e1325859034146.jpeg

Bibliography

Austin, Larry, and Douglas Kahn. 2017. “Source: Music of the Avant Garde: Everything Changes.” Accessed January 24. http://aaaaarg.fail/thing/52b2f8fb307888821400000c.

Barry, Robert. 2017. “Graphic Scores: From the Symbolic to the Indexical - The Wire.” The Wire Magazine - Adventures In Modern Music. Accessed January 24. http://www.thewire.co.uk/in-writing/columns/robert-barry_drawing-towards-sound.

Driscoll, John, and Matt Rogalsky. 2004. “David Tudor’s ‘Rainforest’: An Evolving Exploration of Resonance.” Leonardo Music Journal 14: 25–30 http://www.jstor.org/stable/1513502.

Eco, Umberto. 1989. “Poetics of the Open.” In The Open Work, 1–23. Cambridge, Massachusetts+: Harvard Univerity Press. https://monoskop.org/images/6/6b/Eco_Umberto_The_Open_Work.pdf.

Holzer, Derek, and Mads BEch Paulszewski. n.d. “Rainforest 2012.” http://macumbista.net/files/rainforest_overview.pdf.

Lucier, Alvin. 2012. Music 109: Notes on Experimental Music. Wesleyan University Press. https://monoskop.org/log/?p=12720.

Pritchett, James. 1993. The Music of John Cage. Cambridge University Press. https://books.google.nl/books?id=riHo22Hi8QAC&printsec=frontcover&redir_esc=y&hl=en#v=onepage&q&f=false.

“Realizing Cage’s Cartridge Music | Jaime E Oliver | Computer Music.” 2017. Accessed January 23. http://www.jaimeoliver.pe/recipes/archaeology/cartridge.

“‘Source: Music of the Avant Garde: Everything Changes.’” 2017. Laboratorie New Music. Accessed January 24. http://www.laboratorienewmusic.com/source-music-of-the-avant-garde-everything-changes/.

“Vague Terrain 19: Schematic as Score | Vague Terrain.” 2017. Accessed January 24. http://web.archive.org/web/20150227025105/http://vagueterrain.net/journal19.