User:Max/rwm/theinformationunderstandingmedia

Marshall McLuhan: Understanding Media

The Book

Written 1964, consists of two parts. In Part One Marshall McLuhan describes his theory, in Part Two he analyzes several media that were common in that time. The core of McLuhan’s theory is his definition of media as extensions of ourselves. So with this understanding of the word media anything that extends us is media (glasses extend our eyes, clothing extends our tactual sense, a car extends our legs, a computer extends our brain…). He writes "all technologies are extensions of our physical and nervous systems to increase power and speed". And I think he uses the word media often as a synonym with the word technology. The message is not content but rather "effect". In Part One - chapter two he differentiates media in cold and hot. I looked at this chapter a little closer:

Media hot and cold

In this chapter Marshall McLuhan describes what in his opinion are the differences between hot and cold media. He writes: "There is a basic principle that distinguishes a hot medium like radio from a cool one like the telephone, or a hot medium like the movie from a cool one like TV. A hot medium is one that extends one single sense in 'high definition.'" (p. 22) High definition means that the medium contains many information and the 'audience' (as an example) does not need to complete the content with own interpretation. So a hot medium does not leave so much to bei filled in by the audience. It is low in participation. A cold medium is high in participation and needs a completion by the audience.

I tried to make a short list of what he describes generic for cool and hot media:

hot media

• extends single sense
• high definition
• low in participation
• more mechanical

cold media

• low definition
• high in participation
• organic

As an example he says that a photograph is a hot medium, a cartoon is a cold medium. Radio hot, telephone cool…  And of course: "The open-mesh silk stocking is far more sensuous than the smooth nylon, just because the eye must act as hand in filling in and completing the image, exactly as in the mosaic of the TV image." (p. 29)

He then makes a few examples of hot and cold media. Some of his classifications I could not fully comprehend but I think it is important that a medium is not sticked to hot or cold. It depends and it can change over time, so it is more a dynamic classification than a static one. When new media arrives old media can also change its temperature to the opposite. The medium interacts with other media can heat up and cool down.

James Gleick: The Information

Chapter 2: The Persistence of the World

Walter J. Ong: speech is not a technology / writing is. Speech is more a truer sense of our internal feelings. Writing organizes thought in a technological (non-natural) way. Quotes Platon's Socrates: the invention of writing will produce forgetfulness in the minds of those who learn to use it because they will not practice their memory. -> writing = appearance of wisdom, not true wisdom. -> writing does allow the dead to speak to the living and the living to the unborn. -> writing is a "twisting journey from things to words, from words to categories, from categories to metaphor and logic."

Chapter 3: Wordbooks

"like the printing press, the telegraph and the telephone before it, the internet is transforming the language simply by transmitting information differently. What makes cyberspace different from all previous information technologies is its intermixing of scales from the largest to the smallest without prejudice, broadcasting to the millions, narrowcasting to groups, instant messaging to one"