User:Simon/Annotation typologies: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==from the books | ==traces of book use in ''from the books''== | ||
Typologies identified from a previous project, which explored | Typologies of traces of use identified from a previous project, which explored books from the 000-099 section of the Redmond Barry Reading Room in the State Library of Victoria. | ||
[[../From_the_Books:_SLV_RBRR_000-099]] | |||
ACCIDENTAL DOG-EAR * | * ACCIDENTAL DOG-EAR | ||
* ANNOTATION | |||
* ASTERISK | |||
BOOK PRICE * | * BOOK PRICE | ||
* BOOKMARK | |||
CIRCLED TEXT * | * CIRCLED TEXT | ||
CREASED PAGE * | * CREASED PAGE | ||
* CROSS | |||
DEAD ANT * | * DEAD ANT | ||
DOG-EAR * | * DOG-EAR | ||
ERASER RUBBING * | * ERASER RUBBING | ||
* ERRATA | |||
* FINGERPRINT | |||
* FOLD | |||
HANDWRITTEN LETTER * | * HANDWRITTEN LETTER | ||
INK BLOT * | * INK BLOT | ||
LIBRARY DOCUMENT * | * LIBRARY DOCUMENT | ||
LIFTED PRINT * | * LIFTED PRINT | ||
* LINE | |||
LOOSE PAGE * | * LOOSE PAGE | ||
NOTEPAPER BOOKMARK * | * NOTEPAPER BOOKMARK | ||
* NOTES | |||
PAGES REMOVED * | * PAGES REMOVED | ||
POST-IT NOTE * | * POST-IT NOTE | ||
RECEIPT BOOKMARK * | * RECEIPT BOOKMARK | ||
REPLACED IMAGE * | * REPLACED IMAGE | ||
* SCUFF | |||
* SMUDGE | |||
* SQUIGGLE | |||
* STAIN | |||
* STRIKETHROUGH | |||
* TICK | |||
TORN PAGE * | * TORN PAGE | ||
TORN PAPER BOOKMARK * | * TORN PAPER BOOKMARK | ||
* UNDERLINING | |||
WARPED PAGE * | * WARPED PAGE | ||
WEAR AND TEAR<br> | * WEAR AND TEAR<br> | ||
These formed a loose classification system that indexed these books not by bibliographic reference, but by the frequency of occurrence, taking a "bag of words" approach. | These formed a loose classification system that indexed these books not by bibliographic reference, but by the frequency of occurrence, taking a "bag of words" approach. | ||
Revision as of 16:12, 11 June 2020
traces of book use in from the books
Typologies of traces of use identified from a previous project, which explored books from the 000-099 section of the Redmond Barry Reading Room in the State Library of Victoria.
User:Simon/From_the_Books:_SLV_RBRR_000-099
- ACCIDENTAL DOG-EAR
- ANNOTATION
- ASTERISK
- BOOK PRICE
- BOOKMARK
- CIRCLED TEXT
- CREASED PAGE
- CROSS
- DEAD ANT
- DOG-EAR
- ERASER RUBBING
- ERRATA
- FINGERPRINT
- FOLD
- HANDWRITTEN LETTER
- INK BLOT
- LIBRARY DOCUMENT
- LIFTED PRINT
- LINE
- LOOSE PAGE
- NOTEPAPER BOOKMARK
- NOTES
- PAGES REMOVED
- POST-IT NOTE
- RECEIPT BOOKMARK
- REPLACED IMAGE
- SCUFF
- SMUDGE
- SQUIGGLE
- STAIN
- STRIKETHROUGH
- TICK
- TORN PAGE
- TORN PAPER BOOKMARK
- UNDERLINING
- WARPED PAGE
- WEAR AND TEAR
These formed a loose classification system that indexed these books not by bibliographic reference, but by the frequency of occurrence, taking a "bag of words" approach. Problems that arose were linguistic - it was difficult assigning a word to an example as this already had some assumption of intention (e.g. a doodle as an intentional drawing vs squiggle as unintentional drawing).
thoughts and reflections
Whereas my previous approach was one of identification based on nouns, which presented problems. In a sense, to name something is to own it. Things become property much more easily than actions. Perhaps a different approach of identifying actions may be more open and associative than a noun-based classification scheme.