User:ThomasW/First Proposal Outline v2: Difference between revisions

From XPUB & Lens-Based wiki
No edit summary
Line 32: Line 32:


==Proposal 11.11.15 ==  
==Proposal 11.11.15 ==  
For my graduation project at Piet Zwart Institute I want to question the Utopic view on memory technology’s and the life time- unlimited -secure rhetoric of the manufactures this technology and services....
For my graduation project at Piet Zwart Institute I want to question the Utopic view that any given information storage medium platform is the final solution too our storage problems, by the fact that nothing stays permanent, and have never been, since the beginning of history there have always been promise of the next new thing, the final thing. But history tells us different.
 
I want to explore this question by making collection of work that tells the experience from the individuals level on storage mediums from before or after they fail. How did this change their relationship to whats with them.
Archives takes time, energy and it is sure not to last by itself, if ever. We are get sold easy solutions that never tells us the truth, archiving is hard and maintaining an archive of text and images are something that one really need to think about and not something that can be put in the "cloud" and hope for easy retrieval for future.  
My work will explore different current and past storage mediums like Hard-Drives,USB Sticks, CDs, floppy disks and online “the cloud” storage.
 
'''“We have the capacity to store everything for possible recall, but these same extended memory technologies are capable of generating oblivion in other ways—not least of which is through the technology.” (Gabrys, 2007, p120-123 )“'''
'''“We have the capacity to store everything for possible recall, but these same extended memory technologies are capable of generating oblivion in other ways—not least of which is through the technology.” (Gabrys, 2007, p120-123 )“'''
===Introduction===
===Introduction===
Today we are promised instant relocation and life time storage for free. But nothing is free and how does the it effect our connection to what we make? And how does its supposed easy saving makes us think on the value of what we make and store? Maybe an off-line archive that is under curating by people them self is the better solution?
Today we are promised instant relocation and life time storage for free. But nothing is free and how does the it effect our connection to what we produce? And how does its supposed easy life makes us think on the value of what we make and store?  
My interest in the topic of finding and spread information and knowledge started really early, since I raiding the school library at the age of nine for technology and history books. Later made me make a computer video game magazine project, when I was 13 years old. Collection images, writing reviews, I had folders of images and text and project files. But even how careful I saved them, moving them around from computers to floppy disks to other computers, it all got lost somewhere, stuck on old drives or broken floppy disks, or maybe I myself deleted them thinking they had no future value...
My interest in the topic of finding and spread information and knowledge started really early, since I raiding the school library at the age of nine for technology and history books. Later it made me make a computer video game magazine when I was 13 years old. Collection images, writing reviews, I had folders of images and text and project files. But even how careful I saved them, moving them around from computers to floppy disks to other computers, it all got lost somewhere, stuck on old drives, broken floppy disks, or maybe I myself deleted them thinking they had no future value...


[[File:BASFunlimited.jpg|300px|]]
[[File:BASFunlimited.jpg|300px|]]


 
Now its not computer games, but history itself that is in danger, we put information onto platforms that we say it will archive for ever, “they tell its safe and saved, you don’t need to think about it” but history tells us that platforms and formats never stays forever. If its papyrus or the next “cloud” services
Now its not computer games, but history itself that is in danger, we put information onto platforms that we say it will archive for ever, “they tell its safe and saved, don’t think about, its safe with us” but history tells us that a platform never stays forever. From papyrus or the next “cloud” services
 
“Your data maybe safe for tomorrow, but what about a 50 or 100 years from now? And is it really that important? '''“Digital is the paradigm for content and quantity of information; analogue is the paradigm for usability and interfacing.” (Ludovico,2013,p151)
“Your data maybe safe for tomorrow, but what about a 50 or 100 years from now? And is it really that important? '''“Digital is the paradigm for content and quantity of information; analogue is the paradigm for usability and interfacing.” (Ludovico,2013,p151)
'''
Printed books can last hundreds of years if they are not exposed to fire, water, war and the stupidity of man, but a digital text can disappear and be left unaccessible in the future on the reasons like, unsupported file formats, dead storage media or defunct “cloud” services or new “End User Licenses Agreements” that deny you access to decide for yourself to save or delete.
Printed books can last hundreds of years if they are not exposed to fire, water, war and the stupidity of man, but a digital text can disappear and be left unaccessible in the future on the reasons like, unsupported file formats, dead storage media or defunct “cloud” services or new EULAs that deny you access to decide for yourself to save or delete.  
Online platform or “the cloud” are now often put forward as a final solution for your storage problems, but not even they can guaranty that they still be in business in one months time or what about 100 years from now? By using the “cloud” as a metaphor it makes it even harder for most people to understand what “the cloud” really is, that is in reality traditional computer storage on drives, but just on other peoples machines, somewhere in the world.
Cloud services are now often put forward as a solution for your storage problems, but they can never guaranty that they still be in business in one months time to a 100 years time and by using the “cloud” as a metaphor it makes it even harder for most people to understand what “the cloud” really is.
But by looking back at history, no “format” have truthfully been everlasting without a constant supervision and copying of its content over to new formats and by just having it in one place. But by being aware how things work and being the one that decides whats stays and what gets deleted we can control your future a bit more and past better then letting other people decides, often based on business plans and, for not even paper is foolproof.
 
'''“Cloud storage is so popular, you’d be forgiven for thinking that the old-fashioned back-up drive is simply a museum piece. But if you ask users of the most popular, consumer-focused cloud storage services, you’ll get an earful. Security worries, problems syncing, missing folders, and update errors, are the kinds of issues consumers reported to FixYa, a popular Q&A site.” (Snyder, Online, cio.com)“'''
 
But by looking back at history, no “format” have truthfully been everlasting without a constant supervision and copying of its content over to new formats and by just having it on one place, it will never be stable if ever stable but by the aware how things work and being the one that decides whats stays and what gets deleted, we can control your future and past better.
 
'''“paper was introduced during the ninth or tenth centuries, and the first paper found there is of the oriental type (called bombykinon or bambakeron). The fact that is was cheap than and other material gradually gave it ascendancy, but its rapid deterioration was a matter of great concern to the monks” (Fernando, 2008, p95)'''
'''“paper was introduced during the ninth or tenth centuries, and the first paper found there is of the oriental type (called bombykinon or bambakeron). The fact that is was cheap than and other material gradually gave it ascendancy, but its rapid deterioration was a matter of great concern to the monks” (Fernando, 2008, p95)'''
===Recent observations===
'''“In 1961, the British science fiction author Arthur C. Clarke suggested that “any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.” (Feigelfeld, 2015, Online)“'''
http://www.etsisi.upm.es/sites/default/files/museo/memex.gif  Vannevar Bush /Memex
'''Rather than getting caught up in speed, then, we must analyze, as we try to grasp a present that is always degenerating, the ways in which ephemerality is made to endure. What is surprising is not that digital media fades but rather that it stays at all and that we stay transfixed by our screens as its ephemerality endures. (Hui Kyong Chun, 2008,  p171 )'''
Technology is becoming more distant from the peoples understanding of it, the first to start using a technology know more about how it works than those who become acquainted later. Most computer and computer storage technology’s are mysterious. Its hidden away in black boxes, warning labels and security screws and hyper-bull marketing words.
Loss of control of the personal archive means a loss of societal control of the cultural record. (Abreu, 2008, Online)
Marketing often use words like “life-time” for storage technology and systems. The technology industry have always been “fetishising the notion of optimization” From paper medium to the cloud, there has always people looking for quick solutions
'''“I am afraid that future theorists and historians of computer media will be left with not much more than the equivalents of the newspaper reports and film programs from cinema first decade. They will find that analytical texts from our area recognize the significance of computers take over of culture, yet, by and large, contains speculations about the future rather then a record and theory of the present. (Manovich,2001, p6-7)“'''
=== Possible outcome ===
====Idea 1====
*The outcome will exist in a collection of different storage medium that all will tell the tail of its own short comings. Like  a small six cm tall box located on a table with one drive on top.
The drives will be mounted on the top of the small box. True the old had-drive there will be story’s transmitted true as audio as the drive is rewired to act like a speaker.
I want the people to get close to the drives to hear whats going on. You will only be able to hear noise from a far, but to hear whats being told, you need to get close to the drives. By letting the audience look at the drive close, it may help people better understand how the drive worked
[[File:TwitterHD3.JPG]]
==== Idea 2====
Documentation of current computer history can be taken to unluckily places, a lot of early web history survive on VHS tapes and computer books. Irony is that the books outlast the machines they where made to help use.
Get old web surfing books and explore how much of the books web do still exists and if so, in what form?
Re mix the book and remake with all of the dead links removed..
http://cdn1.tnwcdn.com/wp-content/blogs.dir/1/files/2015/02/keyboard_surfing_the_internet2-406x450.jpg


===Relation to previous practice===
===Relation to previous practice===
'''“It must be understood that as long as art stand aside from the problems of life it will only interest a very few people.” (Munari,1966, p25)'''
''''“It must be understood that as long as art stand aside from the problems of life it will only interest a very few people.” (Munari,1966, p25)'''
During my Bachelor I made a project called “The Library of Babel” based on the short story by the same name by the Argentinian author Jorge Luis Borges. This project was made on the topic of “bit-rot” in text documents. This project got me really interesting in the long term storage of information and how we as society deal with it. A tread that go true my previous projects are always topics that I find interesting, but never get the attention it deservers


During my Bachelor I made a project called “The Library of Babe” based on the short story by the same name by the author Jorge Luis Borges. This project was made on the topic of “bit-rot” in text documents. The project got my really interesting in the long term storage of information and how we as society deal with it. A tread that go true my previous projects are always small or bigger ideas or knowledge that is outside peoples interest and understanding and something I find thrilled an interest to try to communicate.
http://payload252.cargocollective.com/1/9/310277/7352872/IMG_5644.jpg “The Library of Babel”
http://payload252.cargocollective.com/1/9/310277/7352872/IMG_5644.jpg  


In my previus year at Piet Zwart I made the project [[https://pzwiki.wdka.nl/mediadesign/User:ThomasW/An_encyclopedia_of_media_objects#Project_Description Imagery Storage Media]]
In my previous term at Piet Zwart I made the project Imagery Storage Media [[https://pzwiki.wdka.nl/mediadesign/User:ThomasW/An_encyclopedia_of_media_objects#Project_Description Imagery Storage Media]]
 
Since the turn of the century with invention of mechanical and electronic storage devices for storing of information there have been a lot of promises of the durability of the medium from their inventors. The computer industry is 50 years of over promising and under-delivery. If the computer industry can make hyper bull, why not make up my own collection of storage formats?  
Since the turn of the century with invention of mechanical and electronic storage devices for information there have been a lot of promises of the durability from their inventors. The computer industry is 50 years of overprecise and under-delivery. If the computer industry can make hyper bull, why not make up your own encyclopaedia of imagery storage formats? With my random generating encyclopaedia of imagery storage formats I want to make fun of the computer industry and putting a question out to people, If the new formats are so good and as stable as they are being told they are, can they really believe it? The industry have more and more turn over to wanting people to store information on “cloud services” and away from physical formats. But the promises still persist, “We Will Store It Securely For A Life Time”*
With my random generating encyclopaedia of imagery storage formats I wanted to make fun of the computer industry and putting a question out to people, If the new formats are so good and as stable as they are being told they are, can you really believe them?  


[[File:Encyclopedia of storage formats.jpg|600px ]]
[[File:Encyclopedia of storage formats.jpg|600px ]]


===Conclusion===
===Relation to a larger context===
“The design artifacts you leave behind will be your ultimate legacy" (Beirut ,2006, p6)
''''“In 1961, the British science fiction author Arthur C. Clarke suggested that “any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.” (Feigelfeld, 2015, Online)“'''
 
http://www.etsisi.upm.es/sites/default/files/museo/memex.gif  Vannevar Bush’s Memex machine.
Technology is becoming more distant from the peoples understanding of it, the first to start using a technology know more about how it works than those who become acquainted later. Most computer and computer storage technology’s are mysterious. Its hidden away in black boxes, warning labels and security screws and hyper-bull marketing words tell you that This is the final and last thing you will ever need. The technology industry have always been “fetishising the notion of optimization” From paper medium to the cloud, People have always been looking for quick solutions for their problems, storing their memory is one of them.
'''Rather than getting caught up in speed, then, we must analyze, as we try to grasp a present that is always degenerating, the ways in which ephemerality is made to endure. What is surprising is not that digital media fades but rather that it stays at all and that we stay transfixed by our screens as its ephemerality endures. (Hui Kyong Chun, 2008,  p171 )
===Thesis intention===
The thesis will focus on the topic of society and how we generate information, and how we deal with this excering amount of information
'''“I am afraid that future theorists and historians of computer media will be left with not much more than the equivalents of the newspaper reports and film programs from cinema first decade. They will find that analytical texts from our area recognize the significance of computers take over of culture, yet, by and large, contains speculations about the future rather then a record and theory of the present. (Manovich,2001, p6-7)“'''
===Practical steps===
My work will explore different current and past storage mediums like Hard-Drives,USB Sticks, CDs, floppy disks and online “the cloud” storage.
The Hard-Drive part of the project exist now as a prototype in the form of “My Hard Drive Died” where I transmit 750 stories gathers from twitter true one old drive that is reworked as a speaker. The voice are with done with synthesizers voice as it make it more as a voice from the hard-drive.
As the rest of project I need to explore different ruts on where the project can go, On the USB part there have been issue with people buying “fake” USB stick that show a bigger capacity then in it have, so exploring peoples frustration with faulty tech.
'''“The design artefact you leave behind will be your ultimate legacy" (Beirut ,2006, p6)
===Bibliography===
===Bibliography===
==== Books ====
*Gabrys, Jennifer (2007) DIGITAL RUBBISH a natural history of electronics, Paperback , United States of America ,The University of Michigan Press
*Gabrys, Jennifer (2007) DIGITAL RUBBISH a natural history of electronics, Paperback , United States of America ,The University of Michigan Press
*Ludovico, Alessandro (2013) Post Digital Print, Onomatopee
*Ludovico, Alessandro (2013) Post Digital Print, Onomatopee
*Munari, Bruno, Design as Art (1966) England, Penguin
*Munari, Bruno, Design as Art (1966) England, Penguin
*Feigelfeld, Paul (2015) Media Archaeology Out of Nature: An Interview with Jussi Parikka, e-flux.com [Online] Available: http://www.e-flux.com/journal/media-archaeology-out-of-nature-an-interview-with-jussi-parikka/ (Accessed:28.05.2015)
*Beirut, Michael, Drenttel, William, William, Steven (2006) Look Closer Five, Critical Writings on Graphic Design, New York, Allworth Press
*Beirut, Michael, Drenttel, William, William, Steven (2006) Look Closer Five, Critical Writings on Graphic Design, New York, Allworth Press
*Manovich, Lev, (2001) The Language of New Media, United States of America, The MIT Press
*Manovich, Lev, (2001) The Language of New Media, United States of America, The MIT Press
*Baez, Fernando (2008) A Universal History of the Destruction of Books: From Ancient Sumer to Modern-day Iraq, Atlas & Co.
*Baez, Fernando (2008) A Universal History of the Destruction of Books: From Ancient Sumer to Modern-day Iraq, Atlas & Co.
==== Online ====
*Feigelfeld, Paul (2015) Media Archaeology Out of Nature: An Interview with Jussi Parikka, e-flux.com [Online] Available: http://www.e-flux.com/journal/media-archaeology-out-of-nature-an-interview-with-jussi-parikka/ (Accessed:28.05.2015)
*The Enduring Ephemeral, or the Future Is a Memory Author(s): By Wendy Hui Kyong Chun Source: Critical Inquiry, Vol. 35, No. 1 (Autumn 2008), pp. 148-171 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/595632 . Accessed: 22/09/2015 09:06  
*The Enduring Ephemeral, or the Future Is a Memory Author(s): By Wendy Hui Kyong Chun Source: Critical Inquiry, Vol. 35, No. 1 (Autumn 2008), pp. 148-171 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/595632 . Accessed: 22/09/2015 09:06  
*Abreu, Amelia (2015) The Collection and the Cloud, The New Winquiry [Online] Available: http://thenewinquiry.com/essays/the-collection-and-the-cloud/ .(Accessed:10.10.2015)
*Abreu, Amelia (2015) The Collection and the Cloud, The New Winquiry [Online] Available: http://thenewinquiry.com/essays/the-collection-and-the-cloud/ .(Accessed:10.10.2015)

Revision as of 20:21, 12 November 2015

Old version that got to messy, look for older versions Old

108s-Peeboo.jpg

Ideas, thoughts, WTFDIGM

  • Formats: How does the formats dictated your making, collecting,curating memory's?
  • If there was a issue with papyrus and paper, what makes bit root +++ different?
  • Do people care and what happens with the fait in the utopic power of tech when they fail for people?
  • Why do I care?
  • Memory is not history
  • media not stable
  • Does and don’t
  • curiosity cabinet
  • intro.. new or old storage mediums. Pick
  • encyclopedia of storage mediums
  • make info access to everyone.
  • what to save means

Thesis things

  • How does the 2 and 3 law of Thermodynamic relate to storing of information? ++++
  • (Mass production of memory, make things more or less valubal?)

Project tittle ideas

  • Knowledge on the edge of oblivion
  • My memory died
  • My ____ died
  • 404 not found
  • and more


anim0205-1_e0.gif

Proposal 11.11.15

For my graduation project at Piet Zwart Institute I want to question the Utopic view that any given information storage medium platform is the final solution too our storage problems, by the fact that nothing stays permanent, and have never been, since the beginning of history there have always been promise of the next new thing, the final thing. But history tells us different. I want to explore this question by making collection of work that tells the experience from the individuals level on storage mediums from before or after they fail. How did this change their relationship to whats with them. My work will explore different current and past storage mediums like Hard-Drives,USB Sticks, CDs, floppy disks and online “the cloud” storage. “We have the capacity to store everything for possible recall, but these same extended memory technologies are capable of generating oblivion in other ways—not least of which is through the technology.” (Gabrys, 2007, p120-123 )“

Introduction

Today we are promised instant relocation and life time storage for free. But nothing is free and how does the it effect our connection to what we produce? And how does its supposed easy life makes us think on the value of what we make and store? My interest in the topic of finding and spread information and knowledge started really early, since I raiding the school library at the age of nine for technology and history books. Later it made me make a computer video game magazine when I was 13 years old. Collection images, writing reviews, I had folders of images and text and project files. But even how careful I saved them, moving them around from computers to floppy disks to other computers, it all got lost somewhere, stuck on old drives, broken floppy disks, or maybe I myself deleted them thinking they had no future value...

BASFunlimited.jpg

Now its not computer games, but history itself that is in danger, we put information onto platforms that we say it will archive for ever, “they tell its safe and saved, you don’t need to think about it” but history tells us that platforms and formats never stays forever. If its papyrus or the next “cloud” services “Your data maybe safe for tomorrow, but what about a 50 or 100 years from now? And is it really that important? “Digital is the paradigm for content and quantity of information; analogue is the paradigm for usability and interfacing.” (Ludovico,2013,p151) Printed books can last hundreds of years if they are not exposed to fire, water, war and the stupidity of man, but a digital text can disappear and be left unaccessible in the future on the reasons like, unsupported file formats, dead storage media or defunct “cloud” services or new “End User Licenses Agreements” that deny you access to decide for yourself to save or delete. Online platform or “the cloud” are now often put forward as a final solution for your storage problems, but not even they can guaranty that they still be in business in one months time or what about 100 years from now? By using the “cloud” as a metaphor it makes it even harder for most people to understand what “the cloud” really is, that is in reality traditional computer storage on drives, but just on other peoples machines, somewhere in the world. But by looking back at history, no “format” have truthfully been everlasting without a constant supervision and copying of its content over to new formats and by just having it in one place. But by being aware how things work and being the one that decides whats stays and what gets deleted we can control your future a bit more and past better then letting other people decides, often based on business plans and, for not even paper is foolproof. “paper was introduced during the ninth or tenth centuries, and the first paper found there is of the oriental type (called bombykinon or bambakeron). The fact that is was cheap than and other material gradually gave it ascendancy, but its rapid deterioration was a matter of great concern to the monks” (Fernando, 2008, p95)

Relation to previous practice

'“It must be understood that as long as art stand aside from the problems of life it will only interest a very few people.” (Munari,1966, p25) During my Bachelor I made a project called “The Library of Babel” based on the short story by the same name by the Argentinian author Jorge Luis Borges. This project was made on the topic of “bit-rot” in text documents. This project got me really interesting in the long term storage of information and how we as society deal with it. A tread that go true my previous projects are always topics that I find interesting, but never get the attention it deservers

IMG_5644.jpg “The Library of Babel”

In my previous term at Piet Zwart I made the project Imagery Storage Media [Imagery Storage Media] Since the turn of the century with invention of mechanical and electronic storage devices for storing of information there have been a lot of promises of the durability of the medium from their inventors. The computer industry is 50 years of over promising and under-delivery. If the computer industry can make hyper bull, why not make up my own collection of storage formats? With my random generating encyclopaedia of imagery storage formats I wanted to make fun of the computer industry and putting a question out to people, If the new formats are so good and as stable as they are being told they are, can you really believe them?

Encyclopedia of storage formats.jpg

Relation to a larger context

'“In 1961, the British science fiction author Arthur C. Clarke suggested that “any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.” (Feigelfeld, 2015, Online)“ memex.gif Vannevar Bush’s Memex machine. Technology is becoming more distant from the peoples understanding of it, the first to start using a technology know more about how it works than those who become acquainted later. Most computer and computer storage technology’s are mysterious. Its hidden away in black boxes, warning labels and security screws and hyper-bull marketing words tell you that This is the final and last thing you will ever need. The technology industry have always been “fetishising the notion of optimization” From paper medium to the cloud, People have always been looking for quick solutions for their problems, storing their memory is one of them. Rather than getting caught up in speed, then, we must analyze, as we try to grasp a present that is always degenerating, the ways in which ephemerality is made to endure. What is surprising is not that digital media fades but rather that it stays at all and that we stay transfixed by our screens as its ephemerality endures. (Hui Kyong Chun, 2008, p171 )

Thesis intention

The thesis will focus on the topic of society and how we generate information, and how we deal with this excering amount of information “I am afraid that future theorists and historians of computer media will be left with not much more than the equivalents of the newspaper reports and film programs from cinema first decade. They will find that analytical texts from our area recognize the significance of computers take over of culture, yet, by and large, contains speculations about the future rather then a record and theory of the present. (Manovich,2001, p6-7)“

Practical steps

My work will explore different current and past storage mediums like Hard-Drives,USB Sticks, CDs, floppy disks and online “the cloud” storage. The Hard-Drive part of the project exist now as a prototype in the form of “My Hard Drive Died” where I transmit 750 stories gathers from twitter true one old drive that is reworked as a speaker. The voice are with done with synthesizers voice as it make it more as a voice from the hard-drive. As the rest of project I need to explore different ruts on where the project can go, On the USB part there have been issue with people buying “fake” USB stick that show a bigger capacity then in it have, so exploring peoples frustration with faulty tech. “The design artefact you leave behind will be your ultimate legacy" (Beirut ,2006, p6)

Bibliography

  • Gabrys, Jennifer (2007) DIGITAL RUBBISH a natural history of electronics, Paperback , United States of America ,The University of Michigan Press
  • Ludovico, Alessandro (2013) Post Digital Print, Onomatopee
  • Munari, Bruno, Design as Art (1966) England, Penguin
  • Feigelfeld, Paul (2015) Media Archaeology Out of Nature: An Interview with Jussi Parikka, e-flux.com [Online] Available: http://www.e-flux.com/journal/media-archaeology-out-of-nature-an-interview-with-jussi-parikka/ (Accessed:28.05.2015)
  • Beirut, Michael, Drenttel, William, William, Steven (2006) Look Closer Five, Critical Writings on Graphic Design, New York, Allworth Press
  • Manovich, Lev, (2001) The Language of New Media, United States of America, The MIT Press
  • Baez, Fernando (2008) A Universal History of the Destruction of Books: From Ancient Sumer to Modern-day Iraq, Atlas & Co.
  • The Enduring Ephemeral, or the Future Is a Memory Author(s): By Wendy Hui Kyong Chun Source: Critical Inquiry, Vol. 35, No. 1 (Autumn 2008), pp. 148-171 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/595632 . Accessed: 22/09/2015 09:06
  • Abreu, Amelia (2015) The Collection and the Cloud, The New Winquiry [Online] Available: http://thenewinquiry.com/essays/the-collection-and-the-cloud/ .(Accessed:10.10.2015)